Is Christmas Pagan — or a Christian Proclamation? 

by | Dec 17, 2025 | 2025

Many Christians are familiar with those who object strongly to Christmas. The concern is often 

sincere and rooted in a desire for faithfulness. “Christmas is a pagan holiday,” they say. Some point 

to Jeremiah 10, describing the cutting of a tree, decorating it with silver and gold, and conclude, 

“There you have it — the Christmas tree.” 

But this objection rests on a misunderstanding of both Scripture and Christian practice. 

Christians do not worship trees. We do not bow before decorations. We worship Jesus Christ — the 

Son of God, the King of kings and Lord of lords. The Christmas tree, like church buildings, music, or 

candles, is not an object of worship but a symbol that can be used meaningfully or misused. 

Scripture condemns idolatry, not celebration. 

What is central to Christmas is the incarnation: God becoming flesh. When Jesus was born, heaven 

itself rejoiced. Shepherds left their flocks in wonder. Angels announced “good news of great joy for 

all people.” If heaven celebrated, why should the church be silent? 

A common objection follows: “Why celebrate Jesus’ birth around the time when pagans celebrated 

the return of the sun?” 

That question actually reveals something profound about the wisdom of the early church. 

The first Christians lived in cultures already filled with festivals, symbols, and rhythms of life. When 

people turned to Christ, the gospel did not require them to erase every cultural marker, but to 

redeem their meaning. The sun was no longer celebrated — the Son was. Light was no longer 

worshipped — the Light of the world was proclaimed. 

Scripture shows this pattern repeatedly. Gentile believers were not required to adopt Jewish 

customs such as circumcision. Why? Because God is not interested in external conformity, but 

internal transformation. As Scripture reminds us, “The Lord looks at the heart.” 

Yes, it is true: we do not know the exact date of Jesus’ birth. Shepherds were unlikely to be in open 

fields in the depths of winter. Most Christians acknowledge this openly. But the power of Christmas 

does not lie in chronological precision — it lies in the truth it proclaims: “The Word became flesh and 

dwelt among us.” 

Christmas is not about defending a date; it is about declaring a reality. The Truth of a statement or 

symbol is not in the statement or the symbol, but in the reality to which it refers. 

Even today, the fruit of the season speaks for itself. In the retirement village where I live, the 

Christmas season brings a visible surge of kindness, generosity, and care. People visit the frail and 

lonely. Carols are sung for those who cannot be with family. Community replaces isolation. Love 

becomes tangible. These are not pagan outcomes — they are gospel-shaped ones. Everyone around 

the world knows that Christmas is about Jesus, whether they are Christian or not. Nobody today 

associates Christmas with a pagan practice. So, is Christmas “kosher” for Christians? 

Yes — when Christ is at the centre. 

Christmas is not the worship of pagan symbols; it is the proclamation of the greatest truth 

Christianity holds: God entered human history to redeem it. Far from compromising the faith, 

Christmas offers the church a powerful opportunity to rejoice, to witness, and to remind the world 

that light has come into the darkness — and the darkness did not overcome it. 

“But for you who fear my name, the Sun of Righteousness will rise with healing in his wings. And you 

will go free, leaping with joy like calves let out to pasture.” (Mal. 4:2 NLT)